This claim was brought by store-based employees who say that they are paid less than employees based in ASDA distribution centres. Store-based employees are predominantly female while distribution centre employees are predominantly male.
The employees have won the first round in that the Supreme Court has now decided that they are engaged on the same or substantially the same terms as those employed in the distribution centres. This is the first challenge. The Court has basically said that it is not a difficult threshold to get over.
The next step is for a consideration of whether the work is of ‘equal value’. This usually involves obtaining ‘expert’ consultants’ evidence, looking at factors such as skills, training and responsibility.
If the employees succeed in showing that the work is of equal value there will still need to be consideration of whether there are reasons other than gender which explain the differential. In practice if the statistics show that employees in one area are of a particular gender and in the other line of work are predominantly of a different gender the equal pay rules are breached.
The equal pay legislation is extremely complicated. There can be no reasonable argument that if a male and female are doing the same job their pay should differ. However, trying to compare very different jobs at different places of work where on the face of it male and female are equally entitled to apply for either type of job is much more controversial. No doubt readers will have differing opinions on this, what is clear though is that the complexities of the legislation have spawned a highly remunerative business for equal pay lawyers and ‘experts’ appointed to undertake the comparisons between the differing roles.
Nigel Tillott
Angela West
Gareth Price
Birmingham – 0121 616 4450
Latham House | 33-34 Paradise Street |
Birmingham B1 2AJ
Gloucester – 01452 612345
Rowan House | Barnett Way | Barnwood |
Gloucester GL4 3RT
Bristol – 01454 619619
250 Aztec West | Park Avenue | Almondsbury |
Bristol BS32 4TR
West End London – 0207 486 2908
57 Queen Anne Street | West End |
London W1G 9JR
Devon – 01271 533747
The Office | Coombe Farm | Beaford |
Winkleigh | Devon EX19 8LJ
Davies and Partners Solicitors is the trading name of Davies and Partners Solicitors Limited (Company Registration No: 10385547) registered in England and Wales. Registered Office: Rowan House, Barnett Way, Barnwood, Gloucester GL4 3RT. Authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority and its Solicitors Regulation Authority number is 634759. A list of Directors is available for inspection at each of our offices.